At DBA Lawyers, we perform a lot of work regarding non-arm’s length income (NALI): advising on minimising NALI risks, dealing with the implications when it does arise, and much more.
Accordingly, a new case piqued our interest: Maradox Pty Ltd v Normet Industries Nominees Pty Ltd (No 2) [2026] VSC 637.
It is a lengthy case, at almost 200 pages (719 paragraphs) long. This article only focuses on the SMSF NALI aspects. However, there is much more to the case. For those who want the ‘full picture’, visit https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/cases/vic/VSC/2026/637.html
The indirect acquisition of a business by an SMSF
The Paul Sailah Superannuation Fund (PSSF) was an SMSF.
It appears that the SMSF owned 100% of the units in a pre-1999 unit trust.
On or around 12 July 2007, the unit trust acquired 49% of the shares in a company (Norstar Recycling Pty Ltd). Paul and his half-brother Raymond were the only directors of Norstar Recycling. Norstar Recycling ran a valuable business. The business was worth approximately $80 million.
The unit trust acquired the shares from the Sailah Family Trust at a value of $39.9 million. The Sailah Family Trust provided a loan to the unit trust to fund the acquisition of the shares. The loan was interest free.
Norstar Recycling declared and paid dividends (eg, one May 2009 dividend that Norstar Recycling paid to the Paul Sailah Assets Trust was over $4 million).
The ATO reviews and audits
On 1 April 2014, the ATO sent a letter advising that they were undertaking a risk review of Paul’s taxation affairs focusing on the 2010–12 financial years. The ATO was looking at the income of the SMSF and a potential NALI issue.
On 24 October 2014, the ATO wrote advising that it had completed its comprehensive risk review and was now commencing an audit into Paul’s taxation affairs. The ATO identified taxation risks and described the PSSF as being in receipt of NALI in the 2010 to 2013 financial years.
On 21 May 2015, a meeting with the ATO took place. The ATO intended to argue NALI and part IVA dividend stripping (s 177E of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)) and to proceed to a General Anti-Avoidance Rules Panel hearing for an indicative finding.
On 1 October 2015, the ATO sent an email advising that a draft NALI position paper had been finalised. The ATO reasoned that the SMSF’s income exceeded what would have been expected if the parties had dealt at arm’s length. This was because an arm’s length lender would not have provided the loan on those terms, or would have required interest at a commercial rate, which would have reduced the income available for distribution to the SMSF.
The settlement with the ATO
Ultimately, on 9 May 2017, the ATO proposed terms of settlement as follows:
(a) NALI would be assessed to the SMSF;
(b) the income years 2010 to 2012 would not be pursued; accordingly, NALI would apply only in respect of the income years 2013 to 2017 (inclusive);
(c) the balance of the loan (by that stage $28.7 million) advanced by the family trust to the unit trust would be fully repaid by no later than 30 June 2017;
(d) a reduction in the tax liability would be applied to the primary tax payable by the SMSF;
(e) in respect of the income years under review, only the 2013 income year would be subject to an amended assessment by the ATO, resulting in a reduced tax liability of $3,713,030.79. This represented a substantial reduction as the pre‑settlement position contemplated tax payable for the 2011 to 2013 income years in the amount of $7,833,346.79;
(f) No penalties would be imposed in respect of the tax shortfall, however, a shortfall interest charge arising from the amended assessment would be applied up to 31 May 2016.
The SMSF accepted this settlement.
The repayment occurred as a transfer back of shares from the unit trust.
Implications
Paul says that when the loan was repaid in 2017 by the transfer back of shares, his entitlement was not restored and distributions have since been made on an incorrect basis causing significant loss. Indeed, that was what the case was about (it was not a NALI case but a civil claim for damages).
However, from a NALI point of view, we make the following observations. As always, evidence was critical. NALI is a tax matter and thus the burden of proof falls on the taxpayer (ie, the SMSF). Recall the loan was interest free. Here, it appears the SMSF was unable to prove that the terms of the loan were consistent with what an arm’s length lender would have provided.
Naturally, we would be pleased to assist on any NALI or similar assignment.
Related articles:
- NALI & NALE Part 2 — Dividend, fixed trust and non-fixed trust – NALI
- How does NALI interact with CGT –– TD 2024/5
- SMSF Staff Discount Policy –– do you have one?
- NALE legislation finally becomes law
- New SMSF case demonstrates how not to have non-arm’s length income
- NALI/E – urgent fix still needed
* * *
This article is for general information only and should not be relied upon without first seeking advice from an appropriately qualified professional. The above does not constitute financial product advice. Financial product advice can only be obtained from a licenced financial adviser under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).
Note: DBA Lawyers presents monthly online SMSF training. For more details or to register, visit www.dbanetwork.com.au or call 03 9092 9400.
For more information regarding how DBA Lawyers can assist in your SMSF practice, visit www.dbalawyers.com.au.
By Bryce Figot, Special Counsel, ([email protected]) and Daniel Butler, Director ([email protected]), DBA Lawyers.
DBA LAWYERS
6 October 2026
