Advanced search

Top Navigation

SMSFs and rental properties — many taxes to consider — Part 1

Introduction

The ATO is placing increased scrutiny on rental and property related matters as recent ATO data suggests that around 9 out of 10 taxpayers are not meeting the current tax rules.

This is interesting as the superannuation rules add greater complexity on the normal tax rules when an SMSF invests in a rental property, as outlined below.

Advisers must be well-informed about the areas of taxation, superannuation and property to ensure their clients, especially their SMSF Trustees, comply with all relevant rules.

This article focuses on some key tax considerations relating to SMSFs and rental properties, predominantly focusing on residential property investments.

Repairs v improvements

It is critical that SMSF trustees understand the distinction between repairs and improvements.

Broadly, a repair restores something to its original condition. In contrast, an improvement enhances or extends an asset’s useful life.

A repair is deductible whereas an improvement may add to the cost base of the asset for capital gains tax (CGT) purposes.

Deciding between what is a repair versus what is an improvement requires prove ‘tricky’ requiring an understanding of the tax rules and a sound understanding of prior case law and tribunal decisions.

Significant penalties can be imposed for incorrectly classifying these outgoings.

Repairs and maintenance

Repairs and maintenance restore the efficiency, form or function of the asset without altering its original character. These costs can generally be claimed as an immediate tax deduction in the financial year they are incurred. Examples include fixing a broken window or repairing a leaking roof.

Broadly, a repair can only be claimed to the extent the asset is used to produce assessable income. We will cover this point in more detail below given a fund may be wholly or partly in retirement phase or pension mode. Broadly, to the extent an SMSF is in pension mode, it is not entitled to a deduction.

Moreover, it should be noted that initial repairs — those aimed at fixing pre-existing damage or defects that were present at the time of purchase (whether or not known to the buyer) — are classified as capital expenses and are not deductible.

It is important to consider whether a repair that is needed shortly after the purchase of a property is an initial repair as that cost is generally be added to the cost base of the asset for CGT purposes. Invariably, when an investment property is purchased to rent to derive assessable income, there are a range of repairs to undertake to make the property in sound order and condition for it to be available and suitable for rent.

Capital works and improvements

Any works or alterations that improve a property beyond its original state and condition are generally treated as capital works or improvements. According to TR 97/23, an improvement provides a greater efficiency of function in the asset — usually in some existing function. This might involve replacing an existing workable awning for aesthetic purposes or replacing a broken-down water heater with a better quality and more efficient water heater that has numerous advantages over the prior unit.

Improvements are generally not deductible, but the costs might be able to be claimed over the life of the asset via depreciation deductions under Division 40 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) (ITAA 1997) if the asset constitutes plant or equipment used to derive rent.

Alternatively, an improvement may need to be added to the cost base of the asset for CGT purposes and written off over a period of time. Division 43 ‘capital works’ deductions can provide a deduction for building and structural improvements that can be written off, typically at 2.5% per annum, over the ownership period.

A person who disposes of capital works to another person is required to provide a notice under s 262A(4AJA) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) (ITAA 1936) about the transferor’s capital works that allows the transferee to work out how their Division 43 of the ITAA 1997 claim will apply to them. Where a taxpayer is unable to get this capital works information, eg, a landlord cannot obtain from a departing tenant who has made fit-out improvements to a property, they can engage a quantity surveyor to calculate the Division 43 remaining capital works amount.

Depreciation

Division 40 of the ITAA 1997 contains the uniform capital allowance system rules or, depreciation deduction rules. Depreciation deductions are available for most depreciating assets used in the production of assessable income, including plant and equipment. Broadly speaking, Div 40 provides a deduction for the decline in value of depreciating assets based on the effective life of the relevant plant and equipment.

However, from 1 July 2017, a significant change occurred — a depreciation deduction is reduced/denied where the asset is used to derive rental income from the use of residential premises to provide residential accommodation (but not in the course of carrying on a business) and the asset was a second-hand depreciating asset.

For those that can recall, a purchase of an investment property to derive rent from residential premises enabled the purchaser prior to 1 July 2017 to claim the balance of depreciation on any plant and equipment such as dishwashers and hot water services, etc, that was acquired with that property. In the event that the purchaser did not obtain the details of the written down balance of that plant and equipment acquired prior to 1 July 2017, the purchaser could engage a quantity surveyor to prepare a report that would maximise the depreciation claims on any plant and equipment purchased with that property as well as confirming the value of any capital works deduction claims under Div 43.

However, from 1 July 2017 the law changed so that plant and equipment purchased after 30 June 2017 for residential premises would only qualify as a deduction in respect of a depreciable asset if it was a newly acquired asset (and not a second hand one). Thus, where a residential rental property is purchased after 30 June 2017, depreciation can only be claimed on new plant and equipment installed after that date, eg, a new dishwasher.

Note that this change only impacted residential premises and did not impact claims for depreciation on plant and equipment for business or commercial premises. Thus, an SMSF purchasing an office or warehouse can still claim depreciation in respect of the remaining written down value of any plant and equipment that is acquired as part of the acquisition of that property.

Pension exemption — exempt current pension income (ECPI)

Broadly, a deduction in respect of a rental property is only deductible to the extent that the taxpayer derives assessable income. Thus, if an SMSF is say 50% in accumulation mode and 50% in retirement or pension phase, then the fund will generally only be entitled to claim 50% of the amount as a tax deduction under the unsegregated pension method in s 295-390 of the ITAA 1997. This is because, in this example, the fund is only deriving assessable income to the extent of 50%; the fund is also deriving exempt income of 50%.

Thus, the overall tax efficiency of a rental property in an SMSF will depend on whether the fund is in pension mode. A greater tax benefit is obtained from a deduction while the fund is in accumulation mode as the tax saved is typically 15% in relation to each $1.00. However, the overall tax efficiency of holding an investment property in an SMSF may be enhanced if the fund is in pension phase especially if a significant net capital gain is likely to occur in connection with the disposal of the property.

Naturally, you should seek expert advice on what is most suitable to your particular circumstances.

You should also note that if the property is negatively geared, ie, where the deductible expenses exceeds the rental income, you should seek advice on whether it is appropriate to continue a pension. Broadly, exempt income reduces a loss for tax purposes, and since a pension results in exempt income, a tax loss (on revenue account) would be reduced by the amount of exempt income under Div 36 of the ITAA 1997.

Conclusions

Investing in property appears relatively straightforward and for many appears to be a relatively low risk investment for an SMSF. However, as you can see from the above summary, there are many different considerations that need to be taken into account. Moreover, the range of rules, taxes (especially the range of state and territory land tax and related property taxes) and compliance tasks that need to be satisfied by an SMSF investing in property today may result in an investment in property no longer being as attractive as it previously was.

Thus, expert advice should be obtained before purchasing an investment property in an SMSF to ensure the tax and related issues are properly considered and complied with. Naturally, we would be pleased to assist.

 

Related articles:

 

*                       *                       *

 

This article is for general information only and should not be relied upon without first seeking advice from an appropriately qualified professional. The above does not constitute financial product advice. Financial product advice can only be obtained from a licenced financial adviser under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

Note: DBA Lawyers presents regular SMSF Online Updates. For more details or to register, visit www.dbanetwork.com.au or call 03 9092 9400.

For more information regarding how DBA Lawyers can assist in your SMSF practice, visit

www.dbalawyers.com.au.

By Daniel Butler, Director ([email protected]) and Bryce Figot, Special Counsel ([email protected]).

DBA LAWYERS

14 July 2025